The Squelch of the Stand-up: Why Your Agile Rituals are Rotting
The Squelch of the Stand-up: Why Your Agile Rituals are Rotting

The Squelch of the Stand-up: Why Your Agile Rituals are Rotting

The Squelch of the Stand-up: Why Your Agile Rituals are Rotting

When following the process becomes more important than achieving the outcome, you’ve built a runway for planes that will never land.

The Wet Sock and the Unseen Jira Card

The dampness is currently traveling up my left heel, a cold, insistent reminder that I didn’t look where I was walking when I went to fetch the morning coffee. I am standing in a circle of 18 people, and my sock is absorbing the kitchen puddle I stepped in 8 minutes ago. It is a miserable sensation, but somehow, it fits the mood. It’s my turn to speak. I am looking at Sarah, our project manager, who is balanced on a stool, typing furiously into a laptop. She isn’t looking at me. She is looking at a Jira board projected onto a wall that’s slightly out of focus.

“Yesterday, I finished the refactor for the authentication module,” I say, my voice sounding flat even to my own ears. “Today, I’m looking into the latency issues in the cache. No blockers.”

Sarah nods, her fingers clicking across the keys at a rate of roughly 88 words per minute. She doesn’t ask about the latency. She doesn’t ask if the refactor actually fixed the bug that’s been haunting us for 28 days. She just moves a digital card from one column to another. We have been doing this every morning for 108 weeks. We call it a ‘Daily Stand-up.’ We call ourselves ‘Agile.’ But as I stand here with one cold, wet foot, I realize we are just performing a play for an audience of none. This is the project management cargo cult, and we are all wearing headphones made of coconuts, waiting for planes that will never land.

Cargo Cult: Mimicry Without Understanding

During World War II, islanders mimicked soldiers-building straw runways and carving wooden headsets-doing everything right on the surface, but failing to grasp the logistics that brought the cargo. We do the exact same thing, mistaking the rituals (Post-its, $188/hr Scrum Masters, 2-week sprints) for the results.

The Stained Glass Conservator and Material Honesty

The glass tells me when it’s ready. If I try to force the lead came to bend before it’s been properly weighted, the whole panel will bow in 8 years. You can’t schedule the way light interacts with a cathedral floor. You just have to build the frame strong enough to hold the weight of the history.

– Chloe R.J., Stained Glass Conservator

Chloe R.J. manages time without ‘sprints’ or ‘burn-down charts.’ Her mistakes are honest-the result of the material resisting her hand. In contrast, our mistakes are the result of rushing to meet an arbitrary deadline just to update a supervisor’s progress report. We focus on the velocity of our construction from Sola Spaces but ignore the glass.

Rushing vs. Craftsmanship: The Speed Illusion

Rushing Velocity

8 Tickets

Closed per sprint (High Rework)

VS

Structural Integrity

1 Flawless Build

Executed per phase (Low Rework)

The Death of Trust and the Rise of Metrics

We’ve turned Agile into a weapon of micromanagement. The stand-up isn’t a sync among peers; it’s a verbal status report to a supervisor. The retrospective isn’t a place for honest reflection; it’s a 38-minute exercise in polite finger-pointing where we all agree to ‘communicate better’ and then change absolutely nothing.

Story Points vs. Reality

3 Point Task (70%)

5 Point Task (30%)

We argue over imaginary metrics for 158 minutes, ignoring who is actually responsible for the database schema.

In a true Agile environment, managers trust developers, and developers trust managers to clear the path. In a cargo cult, we use rituals as a safety blanket. If the project fails, we can point to the 148 Jira tickets we closed and say, “Look, we were busy!”

BUSY ≠ PRODUCTIVE

Glazier’s Marks: The Lost Pride of Craftsmanship

Chloe R.J. mentioned finding ‘glazier’s marks’-hidden signatures tucked into the lead where no one sees them. They are marks of pride. I haven’t felt pride in a piece of code in a long time. It’s hard to feel pride when you are treating your work like a factory line, churning out increments of ‘value’ measured in pixels and points rather than utility and beauty.

The Difference in Execution

🏭

Factory Increment

Measured in Velocity

💎

Mastered Craft

Measured in Beauty

Unsigned Work

Lacking Pride

Maybe the answer isn’t to abandon the rituals entirely, but to strip them back to their original intent: a quick huddle for a self-organizing team to help each other. If it’s not doing that, stop doing it.

The Bare Foot: Prioritizing Reality Over Script

🧦

Wet Sock

Prioritized over comfort to avoid being 2 minutes late to a meeting.

🦶

Bare Foot

Achieved after realizing the ritual demanded presence, not focus. The old sock was tossed.

We are so busy mimicking the outward appearance of success-a well-organized Trello board-that we’ve forgotten how to actually achieve it: building something that matters, something that stays standing.

Digital Output Velocity

98% Closed

98%

…but no one knows who owns the database schema.

We need to stop filling every hour with ‘syncs’ and ‘alignments.’ We need to give people the space to actually think, to struggle with the material, and to sign their work in the places no one else will ever see.

I have 48 minutes before my next ‘refinement session.’ I think I’m going to use that time to go buy a new pair of socks. And maybe, if I’m feeling brave, I’ll skip the next meeting entirely just to see if the planes still don’t land. What a strange way to build a world.